Easter Eggs – Natural Dye vs. Natural Dye

Easter Eggs Homemade Natural Dye Comparison to Boxed Natural Dye l Homestead Lady (.com)Which natural dyes are best to use on your Easter eggs this year?  There are natural dyes you can make, and then there are natural dyes you can buy.  Here are a few helps for making this seasonal decision.


Its the fight of the century!  The previous years’ champ, the darling of the egg dyes, PAAS was recently robbed of his title due to potentially unhealthy elements in his boxing style. 

The newcomer, the rookie, the plant based Nature Dye has risen to take the crown.  Everyone, everywhere is trying their hand at bringing home the Natural Dye’s style. 

Suddenly, otherwise reserved moms are begging store clerks for their extra onion skins; they’re boiling buckets of beets and figuring out where to buy turmeric. 

Yes, ladies and gentlemen, there’s a flurry of activity in the ring of this year’s healthy Easter – but wait!  What’s this? 

There’s another Natural Dye wanting to duke it out with those boiled onions skins?  This one comes in a box? 

You heard that right, the fans will really be getting their money’s worth today – its “Easter Eggs – Natural Dye vs. Natural Dye!”

Why use a Natural Dye?

Ok, all joking aside, moms are just cool.  We really are.

No matter what the equation, we’re doing our best to do what’s right for our family.  A lot of us are choosing to create a new normal to our holiday celebrations by removing the commercial dyes from our diet.

However, for years we’ve colored our frostings and dyed our Easter eggs with one kind of thing and having to do things differently can be daunting.  Let’s face it, being a mom during any holiday is a lot of work!  Magic doesn’t just happen, you know.

For great articles on why commercial dyes can be dangerous to ingest, just follow these links by Whole New Mom.

One thing we finally decided to do this year was to try a natural dye for our Easter eggs instead of using the little tablets, dropped like Alka Seltzer into a row of colored cups.  There are, thankfully, lots of posts on this topic by quality bloggers.

Here are several and I encourage you to visit them all because each one has a little different experience and varied personal tips.

Once Upon a Time in a Bed of Wildflowers, Homestead Honey, and Herbal Academy of New England

Making Your Own Natural Dyes

Here are some tips for making your own natural dyes for Easter eggs and other projects:

  1. Soak your eggs beforehand in some hot water and a bit of vinegar to see if you can rub off the protective layer that’s over the egg shell.  That layer will come off after it soaks in your dye baths and it can take a good deal of the color with it.
  2. If you’d like to empty your eggs of their contents, just visit our post on Blown Eggs for Easter.
  3. For every cup of liquid, we added a tablespoon of vinegar to help set the color.  To read why that helps, visit this link to the Provident Homemaker – she explains.
  4. If the naturally dyed colors fad a bit as they dry, rub some coconut oil over the eggs to keep them fresh.  Just warm the coconut oil in your hands and be gentle as you apply it.  We use blown eggs for our Easter egg dyeing so we have to be extra careful.
    Easter Eggs - Natural Dye vs. Natural Dye - blues, pinks, purples - www.homesteadlady.com

For more discussion on the importance of family, traditions and fun on the homestead, be sure to check sign up to learn about our upcoming book, Homestead Holidays.  How do we find time for homesteading AND family life?  We hope to answer that question for you with crafts, history, recipes and more!  When you sign up, you’ll receive special offers and bonuses at the release of the book.  
Homestead Holidays Newsletter Sign Up l Homestead Lady.com

Various Natural Dye Colors

  1. I did, indeed, pilfer onion skins from my local grocer to create orange and we opened a quart of our home canned Concord grape juice to make purple.
  2. I simmered some beet for hours to get a deep pink.
  3. Turmeric mixed with saffron was in another pot to produce yellow.  Actually, come to think of it, I’d just run out of plain turmeric so I used curry – the house smelled so yummy!
  4. We boiled a bit of red cabbage to make a lovely blue dye.  With the cabbage, we did one without vinegar and one with vinegar.  The one with vinegar immediately turned the blue dye to pink.
  5. We tried some chlorophyll tincture mixed with a bit of water to make green and it worked, but the green was pale even after the eggs sat in them all night.
  6. We also tried algae from a stagnant puddle at the insistence of my science minded eleven year old.  It didn’t work but it was cool to try.

Easter Eggs - Natural Dye vs Natural Dye - Homestead Lady - Orange, Yellow and Green Homemade Dyes

Natural Dye Results

The onion skin (orange) and the beets dyed the eggs shells immediately – the color just set right away.

The plain cabbage dye and the grape juice dye were the next fastest but if you wanted a good amount of color, the eggs needed to sit for a few hours.

That’s probably the hardest thing about this process – the waiting!  We’re used to a few minutes and nearly immediate color combinations with commercial dyes.

Our first batch of eggs, we left in overnight.  The colors on most were dark and rich.  Overnight was overkill on the orange, though, we decided – they look cool, but they’re reeeeaaaallly dark.  We did another one or two that were lighter orange.

One of the most interesting results came from the purple (grape juice) dye bath.  One jar had vinegar and one didn’t.  Both produced a dark, purple color but they also produced a texture on the shell – almost like sandpaper.

The bath with the vinegar has a more pronounced texture than the one that didn’t.  I’m guessing that there was some sort of reaction between the tartrates in the Concord grape juice and the calcium of the eggshell.  Any scientists out there want to explain what it was?Easter Eggs - Natural Dye vs. Natural Dye - different effects for decorating - www.homesteadlady.com

Commercial Plant-Based Natural Dye?

BUT THEN, we were at Sprouts and my daughter saw a box that said it contained natural, plant based dyes.  Well, how about that?

So, we did another experiment and called it “Easter Eggs – Natural Dye vs. Natural Dye”!  How did they compare?  Well, you be the judge.

The Colors of the Commercial Natural Dye

As per the instructions, we added vinegar to the red, orange and yellow and baking soda to the green, blue and purple.  The orange and the yellow worked very quickly – each had some color within an hour.  We did another dip for about five hours and those were darker.

The red?  Well, um, whatever.Easter eggs - natural dye vs. natural dye - the red didn't quite turn out with the store bought dyeWe struck out on the blue and purple with these, even after leaving the eggs in the natural dye for about ten hours.  It said  you could mix these colors like you would paint but the blue wasn’t blue to start out with – it was a vague, dark color somewhere between really? and wha?!  Easter Eggs - natural dye vs natural dye - no dice with the blue from the store - www.homesteadlady.comThe green didn’t work either, sadly.  My kids were really hoping for a vibrant green but neither the commercial or homemade dye produced one.  We’ll just keep trying.  Any suggestions?Easter eggs - natural dye vs natural dye - no go on the green with commercial dye - www.homesteadlady.comI’m sure this brand of commercial natural dye makes really nice frosting colors but I think we’ll stick to the homemade natural dyes for future Easter egg dyeing adventures.

Easter Eggs - Natural Dye vs. Natural Dye - Homemade dye wins! - www.homesteadlady.com

DisclaimerInformation offered on the Homestead Lady website is for educational purposes only. Read my full disclaimer HERE.

Share All Good Things.

15 thoughts on “Easter Eggs – Natural Dye vs. Natural Dye

    1. Until I started home educating, I didn’t even know that I like science!! What a happy surprise to find that everything is science and its beautiful. Thank you for letting me use your link and a blessed Easter to you, too!

    1. Do you have kids at home? Mine don’t seem to indicate I have an option – we ARE dyeing eggs this year, Mama. 🙂

  1. Love how you wrote you post. I believe natural dyes are the only way to go and they turn out so pretty. Thanks for sharing. Visiting from Wildcrafting Wednesdays. Have a healthy wonderful Easter.

    1. I love it when homemade turns out better than store bought, don’t you? Come to think of it, it almost ALWAYS turns out better than store bought!

  2. Its great that you shared this information. More people should be aware of the chemicals that are putting in their bodies and their children. I have not used chemical food coloring for years. I wrote a post for Valentine’s Day about using beets to make pink frosting.

  3. This is SO neat! Thanks for the reminder on dyeing Easter eggs… I can’t believe it’s almost Easter, I haven’t even thought about it yet. I just realized that next year we will have our own blue Easter eggs straight from our Aruacana hen! I do have some pickled beets in the fridge though.. maybe that’d work for this year? 😀

    1. Absolutely – just use any reserved beet juice from the bottle and you’ll get something that looks really cool. If you have some red cabbage or yellow onion skins, those are easy and effective, too. Otherwise, just enjoy the holiday with your family and plan to rock those Aruacana eggs next year! Being a mom on any holiday is hard so just have fun.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.